Overview of Malignant Catarrhal Fever
Malignant catarrhal fever (MCF) is a frequently fatal disease syndrome
primarily of certain ruminant species, caused by one of several herpesviruses to
which they are poorly adapted. The disease is characterized by inflammation,
ulceration, and exudation of the oral and upper respiratory mucous membranes,
and sometimes eye lesions and nervous system disturbances. The causative viruses
exist in nature as subclinical infections in other species that serve as
carriers, to which they are well-adapted. Two major epidemiologic forms of MCF
are recognized, defined by the reservoir ruminant species from which the
causative virus arises. One, known as the African form, is referred to as
wildebeest-associated MCF (WA-MCF). The other is referred to as sheep-associated
MCF (SA-MCF).
MCF has been recognized as a distinct disease for over 200 years. It was first
described in the late 1700’s, and subsequent mentions of the disease in the
literature are scattered throughout the 1800’s. The association between
wildebeest and MCF in domestic cattle was recognized early on by Maasai
pastoralists and by South African farmers, who referred to the disease as
snotziekte (snotting sickness) (
45,65 ).
Experimental studies on MCF began to appear in the first third of the 20th
century ( 16,17,22,43
). These and other early studies described the basic nature of the disease
and began the process of defining the factors governing transmission of the MCF
viruses between the carrier hosts and the clinically-susceptible species, a
process which continues to this day. A large contribution to the understanding
of MCF was made by researchers in Africa such Plowright et al., who isolated the
wildebeest (subfamily Alcelaphinae) strain of MCF virus in vitro and Plowright
and Mushi, who conducted numerous experiments to examine the basic epizootiology
and pathogenesis of the disease and to define the characteristics of the virus
(for reviews, see
52,64,69
). Knowledge of the sheep-associated agent historically has been constrained
by the fact that it has never been successfully isolated, and studies on its
biology have necessarily used less direct approaches than were possible with the
wildebeest (Alcelaphine) strains, which can be propagated in vitro. Development
of molecular tools to efficiently detect antibody and viral DNA have just in the
last decade begun to enable definitive studies on SA-MCF and to facilitate
recognition of more subtle disease expressions than classical MCF, such as mild
and chronic disease (
10,16,24,56,57
), and recognition of new MCF viruses that originated from neither sheep nor
wildebeest ( 33,35
).
The economic impact of MCF varies widely. The losses have never been
systematically determined, partly because there is no organized, enforced
reporting system for the disease and partly because MCF is seriously
under-reported. In cattle, in particular the European breeds, it is generally a
sporadic, low-morbidity disease, with isolated cases occurring at unpredictable
intervals. MCF outbreaks occasionally reach severe proportions however,
resulting in death of many animals over a period of a few weeks or months (
13,
20,
23,
42,
58,
63
). In Africa, it is responsible for very significant losses to domestic
cattle herds each year, estimated in 1970 to be about 7% annually (
71 ).
MCF is often devastating to operations involving more highly susceptible
species, such as bison, banteng, and many species of deer. The impact is often
seen on deer farms, exotic game farms, research herds and zoological
collections. Over 40% of the annual death losses in New Zealand farmed deer are
caused by MCF (
8 ). The disease has destroyed entire collections of rare deer species (11).
The true incidence is probably even higher than commonly believed, due to the
prevalent under-diagnosis of MCF (
56,
79 ).
MCF is recently emerging as a serious problem for bison breeding and feeding
operations in the U.S.(
55,
78 ).
Bison producers have been put out of business by MCF after their neighbors moved
a sheep flock onto near-by premises. A 2003 outbreak in a bison feedlot in Idaho
has resulted in over 800 head lost, with losses in the vicinity of a million
dollars (Crawford, et al., U.S. Animal Health Association Proceedings, in
preparation).
MCF is present anywhere either of the two principal carrier hosts, the
domestic sheep or wildebeest, are present. Since wildebeest are present in
Africa and elsewhere only in zoos, game farms or zoological gardens, the
determining factor for most of the world’s MCF is the presence or absence of
domestic sheep, which are universally infected with one of the causative
viruses. Sheep exist in virtually all countries, thus the distribution of MCF is
worldwide. Reports exist which document its presence in North and South America,
Africa, virtually all countries of Europe, Indochina, Japan, Australia, New
Zealand, Indonesia, Israel, Russia, the Philippines, and many other countries.
It safely can be assumed that the distribution of the disease is virtually
universal.
The natural hosts for the MCF viruses are found within the Artiodactyl Families
Bovidae, Cervidae, and Giraffidae. Two types of hosts exist:
well-adapted asymptomatic carriers, and poorly-adapted hosts, in which both
clinical disease and latent, subclinical infections occur. The well-adapted
carrier hosts shed virus into the environment and are capable of transmitting it
to clinically-susceptible hosts when contact is sufficiently close, or when
indirect means of transfer of virus, such as suitable fomites, are present.
Poorly-adapted hosts are generally considered not to shed infectious virus, and
therefore to be dead-end hosts. The Families
Cervidae and Giraffidae have to date been found to contain
only clinically-susceptible species. The Family Bovidae contains both
carrier and clinically-susceptible species. Some subfamilies of the
Bovidae, such as the Bovinae tend to contain
clinically-susceptible species, whereas members of other Subfamilies, such as
Caprinae, Alcelaphinae, and Hippotraginae, are generally well-adapted carriers.
Exceptions exist, however, and a full picture of the various viruses involved in
the MCF syndrome and the relative susceptibility of the various mammalian taxons
to those viruses cannot be constructed until more data is available.
Two principal viruses are responsible for most MCF seen in domestic animals. One
exists as a ubiquitous infection in various species of wildebeest (subfamily
Alcelaphinae), and is known as Alcelaphine herpesvirus-1
(AlHV-1). It is present on the African continent and in zoos and game farms
anywhere in the world that these species are kept. The other major MCF virus
exists as a ubiquitous infection in domestic sheep (Ovis aries), and is
referred to as the sheep-associated MCF virus, or Ovine herpesvirus-2 (OvHV-2).
Because of the cosmopolitan distribution of sheep, OvHV-2 is responsible for
most cases of MCF world-wide. MCF of OvHV-2 origin and of AlHV-1 origin cannot
be distinguished from one another clinically or histopathologically. Domestic
goats harbor their own closely-related strain of MCF virus. It has been termed
caprine herpesvirus-2 (CpHV-2) (
18,35 ).
Disease caused by this virus has to date been described only in deer (
14,31,38
). Thus its pathogenicity is not yet well defined.
It is becoming increasingly clear that many other ruminant species harbor their
own strains of well-adapted rhadinoviruses that are very closely related to the
ovine and wildebeest viruses. Some of the viruses appear to cause spontaneous
disease in other species (
35 ), and others do not (
11,51 ).
Moreover, MCF-group viruses have been found in deer dead from MCF, the origin
for which has not yet been identified (
32,33 ). The
known number of ruminant species harboring members of this group will
undoubtedly expand as research progresses. Rather than simply "MCF virus", these
agents are probably more appropriately termed "MCF-group viruses", since the MCF
syndrome can be caused by any one of several members of this closely-related
group.
Perhaps surprisingly, MCF occasionally is found in domestic pigs, producing
acute, lethal disease with typical lesions, due to OvHV-2 (
1,2,41
). Little is known about the epidemiology or pathogenesis in this species.
The domestic rabbit (Oryctolagus cuniculus) is readily infected
experimentally with both wildebeest and ovine MCF viruses, and develops
significant lymphoproliferative disease that may have promise as a comparative
disease model. For references, see Plowright (
64,69 ).
Other laboratory animals that have been successfully infected include the rat
and hamster ( 74
).
MCF is predominantly a disease of domestic cattle (Bos taurus and B. indicus),
water buffalo
(Bubalus bubalis), Bali cattle (banteng) (Bos javanicus), American
bison (Bison bison) and deer (cervid species). However, extensive lists
of clinically-susceptible species of ruminants, primarily belonging to the
subfamilies Bovinae, Cervinae, and
Odocoileinae, have been compiled from cases occurring in zoos and on game
farms ( 27,67
) Both of the two major strains of MCF virus, the ovine and wildebeest
strains, are capable of causing indistinguishable disease in any of these
species. The general factors affecting animal-to-animal transmission such as
viral stability, environmental factors, and spatial considerations are what
would be expected for a herpesvirus: efficient transmission via infected
secretions is favored by close contact and a cool, moist environment. The virus
is relatively unstable in the environment, losing over 99.9% of its titer within
3 hours under hot, dry weather conditions ( 76
). The epidemiology of the two major strains of MCF viruses, the alcelaphine and
the ovine viruses, within their natural, well-adapted hosts differs
significantly from one another, and thus will be discussed separately.
The epidemiology of clinical MCF, that is, patterns of virus transmission from
well-adapted host to non-adapted or ‘susceptible’ host, is better defined for
the alcelaphine strain of virus than for the other strains. In contrast to the
ovine strain, the alcelaphine strain can be propagated
in vitro, more readily induces experimental disease, and can be
reisolated and titrated from tissues and secretions of clinically-susceptible
hosts. Thus it has been more thoroughly characterized. Both strains are shed
into the environment via oral, nasal, and perhaps ocular secretions from their
respective well-adapted reservoir hosts in a manner similar to rhadinovirus
infections of primates and humans. Clinically-susceptible species acquire the
virus through inhalation, ingestion of virus-laden secretions, or through
ingestion of contaminated foodstuffs or water.
AlHV-1.
The wildebeest-associated MCF (WA-MCF) virus (WA-MCFV) is harbored in
all species of wildebeest as a life-long, asymptomatic infection. Viral shedding
by adults is at relatively low levels, except during periods of stress or
parturition, at which time infectious virus titers in oropharyngeal and ocular
secretions rise significantly ( 68
). Although MCF is occasionally transmitted from adult wildebeest, most
clinical disease originates from young wildebeest calves, up to the age of about
4 months. The epidemiology within the wildebeest species involves both
horizontal and vertical transmission. Occasional wildebeest calves are born
infected through the transplacental route. Most calves, however, are infected
horizontally from previously infected cohorts, which develop viremia and shed
virus through ocular and nasal secretions ( 54,69
). Infectivity titers in wildebeest calf secretions exceed 103
TCID50 /ml during peak shedding periods, most of which is cell-free (
50 ). Neutralizing antibody develops by about 3 months of age, after which
viral shedding declines dramatically ( 54 ).
Whereas WA-MCF occurs most frequently in Africa during the wildebeest calving
season, in zoological parks, sporadic cases occur throughout the year. Most
shedding from adult wildebeest is in the form of highly cell-associated virus,
but cell-free virus shedding can be induced by stress (
68 ) or steroid administration ( 77 ).
WA-MCFV is not transmitted by natural means from one clinically-susceptible host
to another; affected animals are dead-end hosts. As opposed to the ovine strain
(see below), WA-MCFV readily can be transmitted experimentally among
clinically-susceptible species by injection of blood or tissue, but little or no
cell-free virus is shed into secretions (
53 ), thus these animals generally pose no hazard for their herd-mates.
However, the virus occasionally passes via intrauterine transmission from
latently-infected domestic cows to their calves (
4,72 ).
OvHV-2.
Experimental transmission of the sheep-associated MCF virus (SA-MCFV)
from a clinically-affected cow to another cow is much more difficult than with
the wildebeest strain of virus. On the few reported occasions where it has been
successfully accomplished, it has required the transfer of large volumes of very
fresh blood or tissue suspension ( 62,81
), suggesting that infectivity titers in diseased animals are lower with the
ovine strain of virus than with the wildebeest strain. Both careful field
observations of many natural outbreaks and substantial experimental data
indicate that horizontal transmission from clinically-ill cattle does not occur
( 20,42
). There are suggestions that transmission of the ovine strain between members
of clinically-susceptible species may rarely happen in some highly
clinically-susceptible species of deer, such as Pere David’s (
28 ).
The epidemiology of the ovine MCF virus within sheep is currently controversial.
Baxter and coworkers ( 7 ) reported that all the
lambs in their study were infected by 2 months of age, similar to wildebeest
calves. Data from the author’s lab however, indicates that transmission of the
sheep virus differs from the wildebeest strain in some significant aspects.
Whereas intense viral shedding from the wildebeest occurs predominantly during
the first 90 days of life, lambs did not begin to shed significantly until after
5 months of age ( 37 ). Although occasional
intra-uterine infections occur in sheep, the majority of lambs are not infected
until after 2 to 2 months of age under natural flock conditions. If removed from
contact with infected sheep prior to that age, lambs remain uninfected and can
be raised free of the virus ( 18 ). This method
is being used by sheep producers and zoos in the U.S. and in Europe (
49 ) to produce virus-free sheep. This supports the concept of delayed,
rather than congenital or perinatal infection of lambs with their MCF virus.
Transmission of clinical SA-MCF occurs both from adolescent lambs and from
adults. Virus is shed from the nose in uncommon, discrete, short bursts between
6 and 9 months of age. Afterward, the frequency of shedding episodes declines.
Adults do occasionally experience shedding episodes, but at significantly lower
rate than adolescents. No correlation between parturition and shedding levels
has been found, suggesting that the likelihood of transmission from a given
adult sheep is relatively stable year-round. Neither is significant virus
present in amniotic fluid or placental tissues.
In contrast to WA-MCF, bovine SA-MCF occurs year-round (
3,20
), with only a moderately higher incidence during the lambing season (
25,49 ). The small increase at this time
could reflect factors other than shedding levels, such as climatologic
conditions and seasonal variations in stocking densities that could influence
exposure intensity. In American bison (Bison bison), MCF is a late-fall
and winter disease. It is likely that the distinct seasonality associated with
the wildebeest strains has historically exerted an unwarranted influence on
judgments about the seasonality of sheep-associated MCF.
The source of virus for transmission is nasal and perhaps ocular secretions in
both sheep and wildebeest ( 50,69
, 34 ). Field observations indicate that the
virus is transmitted most efficiently by intimate contact, but that remote
transmission, presumably by shared water sources, mechanical vectors and other
ill-defined routes is not infrequent. Transmission over considerable
distances—up to a couple miles, has been observed.
A significant feature of the epidemiology of MCF is the often perplexing
phenomenon of clinical cases occurring in the absence of any carriers such as
sheep or wildebeest. Much discussion and confusion has swirled around this
issue, stimulating the postulation of a variety of alternate transmission modes
ranging from insect vectors to horizontal transmission between susceptibles (
5,19,28,60,78
). For an excellent review of early contributions to this subject, see
reference (
64 ). Significant prevalence rates of antibody against this group of viruses
has been repeatedly shown in many clinically-susceptible ruminant species, using
a variety of lab tests (for reviews, see ( 3,44,73,75
)). The respectable seropositivity rates indicate that a large pool of
latent infection by these herpesviruses exists among populations of
clinically-susceptible species. That recrudescence of latent MCFV infections is
a common phenomenon, as in many other herpesviruses, has been shown and
discussed by a number of studies (
61,73 ). However, only lately has its level
of significance begun to be appreciated. Recrudescence will probably eventually
be shown to explain much of the enigmatic epidemiology so commonly observed with
MCF.
The MCF viruses belong to the Rhadinovirus genus of the
Gammaherpesvirinae subfamily of the Family Herpesviridae. The
rhadinoviruses are lymphotropic herpesviruses that share a common genome
structure and are consistently associated with lymphoproliferation. They
persist in nature as inapparent, subclinical infections in their well-adapted
hosts, usually causing disease only when they infect other, poorly-adapted
hosts. It is becoming increasingly evident that the lymphocytes of most, if not
all, species of ruminants are inhabited by their respective resident
rhadinoviruses (
35,44,73
). The rhadinoviruses of primates and humans have received considerable
attention because of their potential role in neoplasia and other chronic
diseases, but their role in diseases of ruminants is just beginning to be
examined.
As with most herpesviruses, these agents are fragile and quickly inactivated in
harsh environments. Experimental transmission between members of
clinically-susceptible species, where feasible at all, requires viable cells
from blood or tissue, which are killed by freezing. This suggests that the
agent exists in a highly cell-associated, perhaps latent, form in the
lymphocytes of the clinically-susceptible hosts, in a manner reminiscent of
primate ( 9
) and human ( 48
) rhadinoviruses.
The transmission of one of the virulent strains of MCF viruses from their
carrier hosts to clinically-susceptible ruminants can initiate the syndrome of
classic malignant catarrhal fever, which is an acute polysystemic disease
characterized by lymphoproliferation and inflammation oriented toward mucosal
surfaces and blood vessels. Reported incubation periods vary widely, and are of
limited usefulness in MCF, as there are numerous complicating factors that
affect disease expression. Recrudescence of existing infections for example,
can occur at any time, giving the impression of extremely prolonged incubation
periods. Estimates from studies of experimental exposures have ranged from 9 to
over 60 days (
28,66,70,82
). Reported incubation periods of several months or more probably represent
recrudescences of previously established infections.
Classical MCF cases are often, but not always, fatal. The case-fatality rate
varies with the species of animal and perhaps with the particular virus
involved. Highly susceptible species such as bison, banteng, and some cervid
species generally experience shorter, more acute courses than do somewhat less
susceptible species such as domestic cattle. It is a common field observation
that those animals that die the fastest are often the ones in the best flesh (
20
). Many deer die within 48 hours of the first signs of MCF, but this time
frame is highly variable. Some cases linger for weeks before dying, and a few
recover. Bison generally expire within 2 to 5
days of initial signs, but occasional animals will linger as poor-doers,
sometimes with vision impairment, for weeks. A higher percentage of affected
cattle than deer or bison will survive longer than a week or so. It has been
suggested that strains of varying virulence exist, some more prone to produce
mild disease and recovery than other strains (
16 ). Mild cases which recover have been observed more frequently in cattle
than in other species (
24 ). Studies indicate that as many as one-third of cattle with clinical
MCF exhibit chronicity, surviving for several weeks to months (
10,56 ) and
developing characteristic chronic MCF lesions (
57 ). A few eventually recover completely, but most either eventually
recrudesce suddenly and die or linger indefinitely as poor-doers.
The disease generally presents suddenly, with little preliminary indications
of illness. Although there are some rather constant signs, there is also
considerable variability in presentation. Typical signs in cattle include
sudden fever, drop in milk production, inappetance, serous discharge from the
eyes and nose with matting of facial hair. Temperature may spike to 106 oF for
a day or two before declining to 103 to 104 oF. Within a day or two of initial
signs, corneal edema appears, typically starting around the limbus and spreading
centrally. Episcleral injection, lid swelling and sensitivity to light are
common. Deep corneal inflammation frequently progresses to blindness within 4
to 5 days. Prolonged inflammation of the cornea can terminate in perforation
and herniation of the iris. Nasal exudate becomes mucoid in character within a
few days, with mucopurulent discharges from the nose, stertorous breathing, and
often dyspnea. Muzzle epithelium is initially inflamed and later necrotic,
resulting in encrustation, cracking and often dislodging of affected epithelial
patches to reveal the underlying inflamed subepithelium. At this stage, animals
are usually severely depressed, and may separate from herd mates and stand
immobile with head hanging. CNS involvement is common, however, and can lead to
hyperexcitability, aggressiveness, twitching, incoordination, nystagmus, and
muscular tremors.
Skin lesions are common in cattle and deer with the ovine strain of MCFV, and
with the recently-described caprine strain, but less so with the wildebeest
strains ( 69
). Areas of erythema and exudation may be found in any area of the body,
including the bulbs of the heels and between the digits. Affected skin often
becomes thickened and corrugated in appearance. Either generalized or patchy
hair loss is prominent, tending to predominate over the cervical region, along
the spino-dorsal axis, or on the medial aspects of the hind limbs. Small
elevated circumscribed areas may be present on the udder or vulva. The skin of
the teats and udder may become inflamed, then dry, thickened and may crack,
leading to fissure formation and scabbing.
The widespread inflammatory process does not spare the joints. Signs of
arthritis may be seen, such as joint puffiness, shifting of the weight, and
reluctance to move. Generalized lymph node swelling is the rule in cattle, and
can often be seen in the prescapular or inguinal nodes. This feature is either
not as prominent or not as easily detected in bison. Diarrhea is uncommon in
cattle, but more frequent in bison and deer, in which it is often bloody. Urine
may be bloody, as hemorrhagic cystitis is common.
MCF clinical presentations were divided into 4 “forms” by Gotze (
21 ): 1) peracute, 2) head and eye, 3) alimentary, and 4) mild. Addition of
a fifth category of “chronic” was proposed by Berkman (
10 ). There is, however, little underlying data on pathogenesis differences
that support this categorization. Although there is some diagnostic usefulness
to the scheme, it should be borne in mind that rather than being distinct and
clearly delineated, there is much overlap between the ‘forms’. The author agrees
with the opinion of Heuschele (
27 ) that the classification is therefore of limited value.
Gross lesions are quite variable, depending on the species affected, and both
severity and duration of clinical illness. The nasal and oral mucus membranes
are inflamed, with either focal or diffuse necrosis, erosion and ulceration.
Erosions may be found anywhere along the alimentary tract, from the muzzle to
the colon. Punctate or larger ulcers are common on the gums, palate, tips of
the oral papillae, esophagus, abomasum, rumen, and both small and large
intestine. Erosions in the esophagus and intestine may be linearly oriented.
Ulcerated areas, often covered by fibrin, are frequent in the mucosa of the nose
and turbinates, as well as in the GI tract. Significant gross lesions are not
common in the lungs per se, other than occasional non-specific interstitial
emphysema. Ocular panophthalmitis underlies the conjunctivitis and corneal
edema. Lymph nodes may be grossly swollen, particularly in cattle. Fibrin may
be found in inflamed joints of lame animals. Bladder lesions are common,
consisting of focal areas of hemorrhage and swelling. More chronic
presentations of MCF can result in prominent renal arteries that are accentuated
by scarring, comprised of intimal, medial and perivascular fibroproliferation.
This lesion is most common in cattle, but is also seen in deer, water buffalo
and occasionally in other species. Other organs such as heart, brain and liver
generally do not exhibit significant gross abnormalities.
Microscopically, infiltrations of proliferating lymphocytes and other
mononuclear cells are found in most organs, with particular orientation to
vascular structures and beneath inflamed mucous membranes. The classic
histologic lesion is inflammation and fibrinoid necrosis of the media of small
muscular arteries, but these lesions may be difficult to locate, particularly in
more rapidly fatal cases. No inclusion bodies are seen in the disease.
Likewise, all reported attempts to demonstrate viral antigens in tissues have
been unsuccessful. Diagnosticians should be aware that significant differences
exist between clinically-susceptible species in the organ-specific character and
severity of MCF lesions (
55,78 ).
Since detailed species-specific descriptions are beyond the scope of this
review, diagnosticians should consult pathology references for specifics (
10,12,26,28,39,40,45,57,69,80,84-86
).
Signs and Lesions. Strong suspicion of MCF should be raised
by animals of a clinically-susceptible species which present with
characteristic signs at a low morbidity rate. A history of contact with sheep,
goats or wildebeest is also indicative, although this contact is often
non-apparent or absent in many cases that are a result of recrudescence.
Swollen nodes, corneal edema, erosive and inflammatory changes in the GI tract,
and skin and bladder lesions are all compatible with the diagnosis.
Pathologists consider the vascular lesions, if present, highly indicative of
MCF. Animals suspected of MCF should be necropsied promptly upon expiration or
euthanasia, as autolysis is often significant in large animals. Tissues (lymph
node, spleen, lung, kidney, brain, gut, thyroid, adrenal, affected skin, etc.)
should be submitted for histological examination fixed in formalin as usual.
Fresh tissues should be promptly refrigerated and submitted unfrozen to provide
a source of DNA for demonstration of viral DNA by PCR (6
,30,35
): the definitive lab test for acute MCF. The tissues may also be needed to
rule out other differentials such as mucosal disease and IBR by virus isolation
or other means.
PCR. EDTA-anticoagulated blood should be submitted from
live animals for PCR on peripheral blood leukocyte DNA. Any animals that are
ill from MCF will have sufficient levels of viral DNA in their leukocytes and
tissues to detect readily by PCR. If fresh blood or tissue is not available,
PCR (
15,83 ) and
in situ hybridization ( 46 ) effectively can be run on DNA extracted from fixed,
embedded tissues, assuming fixation time did not exceed 3-4 weeks. For
longer-term storage, tissues can be preserved for PCR in 70% to 80% ethanol (
15 ). Careful PCR primer selection by the lab is important, as PCR tests
are generally specific for a given strain of virus. For example, primers
currently in widespread use for the sheep agent (OvHV-2) (
6 ) will not
detect DNA of the wildebeest agent (AlHV-1), nor of the recently-described goat
virus (CpHV-2). Until broader-spectrum primers for specific detection of the
entire MCF-group of viruses are developed, the clinician should inform the
laboratory as to which MCF agent is suspected in order to guide the lab in
selection of appropriate primers.
Serology. A broad array of serological assays has been used
to detect antibody against MCF viral antigens. These are generally run only in
a few laboratories in each country. Personnel of most diagnostic labs will
forward samples to appropriate labs that are capable of MCF testing. Serologic
tests that have been used include viral neutralization, complement fixation,
indirect immunofluorescence or immunohistochemistry, direct-binding ELISA, and
competitive-inhibition ELISA (CI-ELISA). Viral neutralization tests utilize the
Alcelaphine virus for a neutralization target, and are reliably specific for the
MCF group of viruses. Neutralizing antibody against the sheep agent
cross-reacts with the Alcelaphine virus, albeit weakly, so that it has been used
to detect antibody against OvHV-2 as well as AlHV-1. Polyclonal assays other
than viral neutralization can suffer from non-specificity arising from
well-documented sharing of antigens between different herpesviruses (
27,44 ) and
thus require very careful interpretation on the part of the operator. The
viral neutralization test, though a highly specific assay for anti-MCF antibody,
is labor-intensive and expensive, and works better for antibody against the
Alcelaphine group than the ovine or caprine viruses. The CI-ELISA, a
monoclonal-based assay that is specific for the antibody against the MCF group
of viruses is specific, rapid and economical. Reagents for this assay (
36 ) are commercially available, and the number of labs offering the test
are increasing.
Serological results must be interpreted with certain features of MCF in
mind. Animals that die quickly may not develop detectable levels of antibody
prior to death. Also, the significant percentages of cattle, bison and other
clinically-susceptible species that are latently infected provides a sizeable
pool of clinically-normal seropositive animals. Thus the presence of antibody
alone is not etiologically diagnostic. This requires demonstration of
significant levels of viral DNA in the blood or tissues by PCR. The main
usefulness of serology is surveying for subclinically-infected individuals in a
herd.
No practical, consistently-effective treatments are available. Many
therapeutic attempts have been described, including the use of corticosteroids,
antibiotics, antivirals, vitamins, and other supportive treatments. Occasional
reports exist of recovery of cattle following treatment, typically with
corticosteroids (
47,59 ), but
the role of the treatment remains to be proven, since significant numbers of
cattle also recover without treatment (
24,29,56
).
Preventing contact between carriers and clinically-susceptible species
remains the primary control method. Scrupulous care should be taken to avoid
allowing sheep, wildebeest, and goats to come into contact with deer, bison,
Bali cattle, water buffalo, and to a lesser extent, European breeds of cattle.
Operations that depend upon mixing species, such as petting zoos, may wish to
consider producing their own virus-free sheep or goats (
18 ). Reduction of stress also is beneficial in reducing the number of
cases, particularly with the more susceptible species. No vaccine is
available.